Monday, January 24, 2011
Whale Rider Part 2: Do traditions need to change?
Ever since Kahu was an infant she possessed and demonstrated characteristics of the next leader. Tradition and customs would not allow a girl to be the 'one'. Koro continued to search for the one and tested his young boys to see who could be it. When his boys could not find the stone he challenged them to he wept. Kahu realizing this proved herself yet again to be the 'one' when she retrieved "his stone" (Ihimaera 92) from the bottom of the sea. Events began to arise that called and showed the need for the next 'one' such as the whales beaching themselves specifically the elder bull whale. These events demonstrated the change in tradition allowing the tribe to stay alive. When the whale was beached and the males' efforts failed to get it back in the ocean the women, who were typically not included in tribal affairs, were called in to help. At the end of the novel after Kahu proved to be the Whale Rider, Koro realized tradition is meant to be changed. He came to the conclusion that surviving is more important than keeping ancient customs. Koro apologizes for the times he shunned Kahu and his ignorance in not realizing she was the 'one' When she was born he only wished for a boy due to tradition and wanted nothing to do with her, now she is "the best great-grandchild in the whole wide world"(149).
Kahu, the Whale Rider
By the end of Ihimaera’s novel, The Whale Rider, it is clear that Kahu is the whale rider. She is the descendant of Paikea and all of the Maori tribe is witness to these events. Even the stubborn Koro Apirana must admit that the young Kahu is indeed the one who will succeed and rule over the Maori people, despite the fact that she is a woman. According to Koro, the men are the sacred ones and the ones who must lead the tribe. However, Kahu proves them all wrong in the end. The tragedy of the whales stranding themselves on the shore and dying was a real shame and Koro took this to heart. He knew that something was wrong and that it was a sign that the end was near. When their great ancestor, the bull whale, appeared on shore, Koro knew that the fate of the tribe depended on whether the great whale lived or died. The men tried and tried but could not get the beast to swim back out. It was as if it was waiting for its master. When no one was looking, young Kahu mounted the beast and showed everyone who she really was, the descendant of Kahutia Te Rangi.
Even up to the last minute, Koro assumed that it was a boy who mounted the whale when he gasped, “Which of the boys?” This event it showed how stubborn and conventional Koro was. It took the second coming of their leader to convince him that Kahu was meant to lead the tribe and was in fact of great importance to the Maori people. Although in the end, he admits that he should have been more aware of the signs such as when she bit his toe. However, his heart was filled with love regardless when she returned to her people. He admits his mistake in pushing her aside and tells her that he had been wrong from the beginning. The best grandchild he could have ever wanted was born and he couldn’t see past her gender. It proves that sometimes our beliefs can make us blind to the truth. In this case Koro was not only blind but he was also deaf, dumb and stubborn. The best lessons can be the hardest to learn.
Whale Rider
In class we discussed how Kahu, althought possesses the traits of the founder, Kahutia Te Rangi, she still acts as the element of revolution. This paradox is further displayed in the second half of the book; and is accompanied by the mystical as well as the realistic. Kahu’s similarity to the founder begins with the picking of the stone on the bottom of the ocean. Traditionally, it is a boy’s role; specifically the future leader’s role. Kahu’s success in obtaining the stone is a direct indication of her role as the future leader of the tribe. By doing so, Kahu continues yet breaks the Maori tradition at the same time. She is certainly not a boy; but her success definitely fits the leadership role. This event is further signified by the repeated phrase, Haumi e, hei e, taiki e, let it be done.
Ihimaera continues this contradiction into the immediate chapter. Normally, up to this point of the book, the mystical portion is related by italicized texts. As we said in class, italicized texts are “not plain, and somehow elevated”. However, for the first time, the tale of the whales, is transformed from italicized to plain, from mystical to reality. It foreshadows Kahu’s coming role of being the one. This theme is highlighted when people said “Talk to the whales. They understand. They understand.” (Ihimaera, 105) People are literately communicating with the whales and into the past. Additionally, Koro analyzes the coming of the whales as “both [real and supernatural]. It is a reminder of the oneness that the world once had” (Ihimaera, 117). What we experience in the present is rooted in the past. The present is tightly knitted with the past and are no longer two separate entities. On another note, the whales from the past are coming to look for the new leader. What they bring with them is the Maori tradition. What they desire to seek is the beginning of a revolution, a female rider. Kahu no doubt embodies both. Kahu, a real person’s interaction with the whales from the past is presented in the form of italicized text. It symbolizes the oneness of time. It symbolizes the oneness of tradition and novelty. It symbolizes that Kahu is just as a leader in the present as she is in the past, or even in the future.
Whale Rider Part 2
In reading the second half of Witi Ihimaera’s novel The Whale Rider, I found one very interesting aspect of the story that is present throughout and even in the first half of the book. The author does an excellent job of using foreshadowing as part of the story. While reading through the novel and examining the text further, I found that Witi Ihimaera uses the end of most of his chapters to foreshadow what will happen further along in the book.
Chapter Fourteen of The Whale Rider starts with the story of the actual Whale Rider, Paikea. This chapter is narrated by an unknown source. The narrator explains to the reader the relationship between the whale rider and the ancient whale. The whale rider tells the great whale, “Friend, you and I must take the gifts of life to the new land, life-giving seeds to make it fruitful.” They eventually arrive in Whangara. The whale rider leaves the whale and after waiting for a while, the whale realizes that he and his companion may be separated. The rider has found a woman and has married her. They eventually go on one last ride together and the rider tells the whale “My destiny lies here. As for you, return to the Kingdom of Tangaroa and to your own kind.” The whale then leaves, heartbroken and longing for his companion.
The text of the story then changes to italics. The ancient whale is with his family in Antarctica. They reach a wall of ice, which prevents them from moving forward. The ancient whale longs for his companion to guide him past the ice. Suddenly he sees his companion and begins to swim, his family following him.
Chapter Sixteen starts with something happening in Whangara. As foreshadowed in Chapter Fourteen, something is happening. Rawiri states that “Whatever the case, the earlier stranding of whales was merely a prelude to the awesome event that followed, and event that had all the cataclysmic power and grandeur of a Second Coming.” As a storm approaches, Rawiri notices, “With it came the icy cold winds hurled from the Antarctic.” From this statement I knew that the whales were coming to Whangara all the way from Antarctica to find their Whale Rider.
Kahu, The Whale Rider
Kahu, The Whale Rider
Upon finishing “The Whale Rider” it can be seen very evidently that Kahu is the whale rider. She is the seed of life planted by Paikea’s spear for the Maori village. Throughout the novel, there are many events that foreshadow her emergence as the chosen one. Exemplified mainly in the second half of “The Whale Rider” many actions and characteristics of Kahu resemble those of the original Paikea.
As we spoke about in class, Kahu shows the same oneness with whales and with nature that Paikea had. Her actions, natural talents, curiosity, and love all foreshadow her becoming the chosen one for the Maori people. Kahu’s interest in the Maori culture shows her deep connection with the tribe, both present and historical. As she presents a speech about her love for her grandfather, Koro, at her school’s cultural event, she speaks in her native Maori tongue. This action depicts not only her ability to speak the ancient language, but shows her deep love for her grandfather, her genealogy, and for the Maori people and culture. This same love for the people and culture can be seen in Paikea as he gives the life-giving spear to the island, giving up his life in the sea for a life on land. Rawiri and Nanny Flowers can also see the virtues that Kahu possesses, noticing how she has no guile, envy, or jealousy.
Throughout Kahu’s life it can be seen that she longs for the sea, moaning like the whales she has seen in videos as she stars across the ocean. Her oneness with the sea can be seen, as she is able to dive deep into the ocean to retrieve Koro’s stone. While underwater, she is also seemingly able to communicate with the dolphins. Kahu’s oneness with the sea and with nature is rival only to that of Paikea’s. Her resemblance to Paikea is culminated when she is able to save the ancient bull whale, soothing him and convincing him that she is in fact Paikea herself.
Koro's Transformation and How This Saved the Future of Their Tribe
In the first half of The Whale Rider, Koro is unable to cope with the possibility of change. Koro sees importance in tradition and tribal customs; however his judgments are not consistent with keeping all traditions alive. Although Koro appears to be ifnorant of the changes and signs of revolutions that are in front of him, it is eventually impossible for Koro to ifnore the connections between Kahu, the whales, and the founder of their tribe. Koro's changes prove the importance of accepting change, acknowledging family, and putting the importance of family before traditions. Koro's changes caused a chain reaction which allowed for the survival of the tribe as well as strengthen his relationship with his family.
If Koro had been aware of Kahu's importance to the future of their tibe, he would have acted differently. Only because he had gone through a transformation, Koro was able to ask both the men and women for help in saving the whales. The moment when the whole town, both men and women, were fighting against the ocean and working together to save the whales marks the moment where Koro's transformation begins. If Koro had not changed, the whales may have never survived because kahu and the other women would never have been allowed on the beach in the first place. Not only did Kahu's actions cause a change in Koro's actions as a leader, but it also caused a change in Koro's attitude towards his family. He focuesed on mending his relationship with Kahu, suddenly realizing that he should have seen the signs all along and should not have been so stubborn and in denial. HIs relationship with Nanny Flowers also changed. There was no tension between them. If Koro and nanny Flowers had never resolved their problems in the hospital room, Kahu never would have woken up from her coma. Once Kahu woke up, Koro was aware of the potential in her that he was unable to see before, solely because he was blinded by both tradition and prejudice. Seeing the capabilities of Kahu made Koro realize the potential in orthers, which made him a more compassionate leader who was ready to embrace change and begin new traditions, while maintaining a strong connection with their tribe's past.